"How do we live transformed - fully human - rather than collapsing our identity into our vocations and callings?"

Spiritual direction for Pastors and Ministers

Jan 18, 2025
About the Author


As Christians, are we shaping ourselves into authors, pastors, leaders, writers, artists, and creatives, or are we allowing ourselves to be transformed?



CONTENTS
+  Do not disturb?
+  Inhabiting Vocations?
+  Larry and our first meeting
+  Shaping ourselves or being shaped?


As Leaders, Pastors and Ministers, do we unknowingly lay out a “welcome” mat for others while hanging a “do not disturb” sign over our own lives?

Do not disturb?

What follows is an uncomfortable comment from Dr. Larry Crabb on spiritual formation to pastors / leaders (all of us I think) on life-changing relationships. Crabb was a psychologist, author and spiritual director - more on him a little later. Here’s his comment:


"We must admit that simply knowing the contents of the Bible is not a sure route to spiritual growth. There is an awful assumption in evangelical churches that if we can just get the Word of God into people’s heads [theology], then the Spirit of God will apply it to their hearts. That assumption is awful, not because the Spirit never does what the assumption supposes, but because it excused pastors and leaders from the responsibility to tangle with people’s lives. Many remain safely hidden behind pulpits [lecterns], hopelessly out of touch with the struggles of their congregations [those around us], proclaiming the Scriptures with a pompous accuracy that touches no one. Pulpits should provide bridges, not barriers, to life-changing relationships"

Dr. Larry Crabb

Crabb wrote that comment nearly four decades ago, in 1988. He passed away in 2021. I knew him and he was never interested in lobbing self-righteous grenades. Anyone familiar with his life’s work (his books I’d readily recommend) knows he was at the forefront of his generation, and perhaps the next, centering on how true formation begins in relationship, growing with God and with others toward a Christ-like life.

A margin note to Crabb’s comment - if that sentence above is true now, and I think it is, then it may also mean that pastors / leaders can easily remain relationally theorist, whilst the Trinity are relational.

Inhabiting roles?

Do not disturb? Is it easy to hide behind role and function, perhaps more so behind a lectern?

From my years in church communities, I’ve seen many pastors inhabit the role for so long that they lost, or perhaps never knew, who they were apart from their vocation. Others were deeply mission-driven yet remained personally untransformed. Their work subtly was/became self-serving rather than genuinely orientated toward the people or communities they were a part of. I hasten to add that I don’t think this is usually intentional but leadership does offer a kind of professional and practical shelter that’s easy to hide behind.


"Your knowledge [of God] counts for nothing unless your friends know you have it, meaning you ‘have it’ in the way you live its truthfulness before others?"
James M Houston

From the start of a career or over time, a job and or role can begin to define our identity and sense of worth (I speak from personal experience with the job category!), shaping not only how we practice faith, but how we relate to everyone around us. A passion for ministry, service, spiritual direction or even proclaiming the gospel (in whatever form) is not the same as a lived devotion to Christ Himself. The former can be theologically performed; the latter requires individual surrender and personal transformation. Following Christ is less about inhabiting a role or vocation and more about being continually and relationally transformed into His likeness. And we are each addressed personally, within the details of our own lives, and shaped there. Which naturally leads me to ask - what is God up to in your life? How do people around us, particularly those nearest to us, experience us?

Back to Larry and our first meeting

Dr Larry Crabb was a psychologist, author and spiritual director. He served as Distinguished Scholar in Residence at Colorado Christian University, and spiritual director for the American Association of Christian Counselors. Larry was also an accomplished, and a hilarious, Elvis impersonator!

My first introduction to Crabb was in the closing years of the 90s. I read his book “Finding God”, which was part of a book syllabus on a relational formation course I was attending (although it wasn’t labelled as such). My initial thoughts on reading his book were, doesn’t this man Crabb know the good news of the gospel?! But there was something in Larry’s book that resonated beneath the surface which I couldn’t put my finger on. Curiosity is sometimes known by another name, hunger. I met Larry in 2002 when I had unknowingly confused my own job with who I was. From the first half hour, at our first conversation, he was gently uncompromising. Crabb was a man who attracted me to a God who was already forming me in life-changing ways. And I got to know Larry better over subsequent years (he was a serious man of faith but also a wonderfully humorous hilarious person). However, in that first conversation with Larry, I really didn’t receive his comments to me at all well; but they were divinely inspired, indeed life-changing, for which I am deeply grateful. And that is another story all together.

Shaping ourselves or being shaped?

As Christians, are we shaping ourselves into authors, pastors, leaders, writers, artists, and creatives, or are we allowing ourselves to be transformed? What’s the difference? A transformed life calls us into being fully alive and fully human, rather than collapsing our identity into our vocations and callings.

Pastors and Ministers, if you’d like an informal conversation over a coffee, around your life and your faith, get in touch.

-Andy.



Journal  Ministry of Imagination  Latest thoughts

Jun 2, 2026
Writers, Authors, Publishers, Pastors, Ministers, Leaders, Creatives

"Spiritual direction: Relationship rather than a Service. Four questions to ask when considering spiritual direction and a spiritual director."

Apr 2, 2026
Writers, Authors, Publishers

"What does our writing and publishing say about us?"

Feb 4, 2026
Leaders

 "Is a better educated mind the same as a transformed mind?"

Jan 18, 2026
Pastors, Ministers

"How do we live transformed rather than collapsing our identity into our vocations and callings?"

Jan 12, 2026
Writers, Authors, Publishers, Leaders, Creatives

"A new encounter is new - transformation arrives from beyond ourselves."

Dec 29, 2025
Artists, Creatives

"Thoughts on “At Eternity’s Gate”, the biopic of Vincent Van Gogh, and on becoming tired of our own, sometimes inexhaustibly creative answers."

Jan 30, 2025
Introducing: Ministry of Imagination Journal


1 "Andy Maitland, iPad drawings, An Imagined Garden One, from figurative to abstraction 2011-22".
This work sits within a wider practice of imagination, art, and reflection: Ministry of Imagination